Decision details

The Publication stage of the Local Plan has ended. Further issues have arisen for the Council to consider before submitting the Plan for examination.

Further to Minute No. 16 of the Cabinet meeting held on 3 July 2015, the Council considered the report of the Director of Built Environment which provided an update of key issues arising from the publication of the Local Plan and changes which have taken place since then, prior to the Plan being submitted for examination. The Council on 22 January 2015 had resolved to approve the draft Local Plan for publication and then submission to the Secretary of State for examination unless there was any material change to circumstances. The Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG) had subsequently updated their household projections in February 2015 and further work had been carried out to assess the implications of these for Sefton. These projections had been anticipated, and it had been expected that the housing requirement figure contained in the draft Plan would be able to accommodate any modest change which might result from these updated projections.

The report indicated that over the full 25 year period 2012-2037, the 2012-based household projections published by the DCLG in February 2015 projected annual household growth in Sefton of 533 per annum. This was a significant increase on the previous 2011-based (Interim) projections of 400 per annum between 2011 and 2021, and the 2008-based household projections of 323 per annum between 2008 and 2033. When comparing the 2012-based household projections of 533 per annum with the 2008-based projections of 323 per annum, this was a 65% increase, which was one of the highest rises experienced by any authority in the country.

This unexpected rise related in large part to under-recording of population in Liverpool during previous population projections and the incremental net migration to Sefton arising therefrom. This only came to light as information from the 2011 Census fed through into the most recent projections. This had been compounded by an ageing population and other trends in household formation in Sefton which had resulted in a growth in smaller households. The cumulative effect of all of these various factors had been significantly higher levels of household growth in the Borough than shown in previous household projections.

The Council’s consultants NLP had previously calculated the level of “objectively assessed needs” for housing in Sefton and they had updated their analysis to take account of the latest household projections. However, any update of this kind had to reflect the latest employment forecasts, as required by paragraph 158 of the National Planning Policy Framework. These employment forecasts, and the consequent labour supply implications, had also gone up significantly since earlier forecasts which were reflected in the housing land requirement contained in the draft Local Plan.

The report set out three potential options as to how the Council might respond to the updated analysis of objectively assessed needs for housing in Sefton which had been produced after taking legal advice from Counsel.

It was moved by Councillor Maher, seconded by Councillor Hardy:

That:

(1)       the Local Plan be submitted for examination using the current agreed objectively assessed needs for housing of 615 a year;

(2)       the Council commits to an immediate review of the draft Plan;

(3)       as part of the Duty to Co-operate, the Council will collaborate with the other Liverpool City Region authorities to carry out a sub-regional Housing study, Employment study and Green Belt study; and

(4)       officers urgently review and update the ‘Consequences Study’, and undertake further work reviewing the economic forecasts, social impact and related labour supply issues.

Following debate and in accordance with Rule 93 of Chapter 4 in the Constitution, the voting on the Motion was recorded and the Members of the Council present at the time, voted as follows:

FOR THE MOTION:

Councillors Atkinson, Bradshaw, Brennan, Byrom, Carr, Carragher, Cluskey, Cummins, Dams, Dowd, Friel, Gatherer, Grace, Hale, Hardy, John Kelly, John Joseph Kelly, Kerrigan, Killen, Lappin, Dan T. Lewis, Maher, McGinnity, McKinley, Moncur, Murphy, O’Brien, Owens, Page, Robinson, Roche, Sayers, Spencer, Thompson, Tweed, Veidman, Webster and the Mayor.

AGAINST THE MOTION:

Councillors David Barton, Bliss, Booth, Dawson, Dutton, Lord Fearn, Hartill, Jamieson, Jones, Keith, Daniel Lewis, McGuire, Preece, Shaw, Weavers and Welsh.

The Mayor declared that the Motion was carried by 38 votes to 16 and it was

RESOLVED:

That:

(1)       the Local Plan be submitted for examination using the current agreed objectively assessed needs for housing of 615 a year;

(2)       the Council commits to an immediate review of the draft Plan;

(3)       as part of the Duty to Co-operate, the Council will collaborate with the other Liverpool City Region authorities to carry out a sub-regional Housing study, Employment study and Green Belt study; and

(4)       officers urgently review and update the ‘Consequences Study’, and undertake further work reviewing the economic forecasts, social impact and related labour supply issues.