Agenda item

Planning Appeals Report

Report of the Chief Planning Officer

Minutes:

The Committee considered the report of the Chief Planning Officer on the results of the undermentioned appeals and progress on appeals lodged with the Planning Inspectorate.

 

Appellant

 

Proposal/Breach of Planning Control

Decision

Mrs. D. Robinson

EN/2022/00565 (APP/M4320/C/23/3314378) - 9 Park Avenue Lydiate Liverpool L31 0BT - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for, without planning permission and within the last four years, the erection of a dormer extension to the rear, replacement of existing front dormer flat roof to a dual pitch roof and removal of hipped roof to provide a gable with a dual pitch roof.

 

Dismissed

 

11.09.23

Mr. Z. Murphy

EN/2023/00013 (APP/M4320/C/23/3315775) - 36 Bailey Drive Bootle L20 6HA - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for, without planning permission and within the last four years, the erection of a single storey extension to the front, a single storey extension to the rear, two storey extension to the side and the installation of a hip to gable conversion following demolition of the existing rear single storey extension and removal of existing chimney stack.

 

Dismissed

 

11.09.23

Mr. Z. Murphy

DC/2022/01670 (APP/M4320/W/23/3314388) - 36 Bailey Drive Bootle L20 6HA - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for the erection of a single storey extension to the front, two storey extension to the side and a single storey extension to the rear, following demolition of the existing rear single storey extension and removal of existing chimney stack (resubmission of DC/2021/02397)

 

Dismissed

 

11.09.23

Mr. B. Davenport

EN/2022/00447 (APP/M4320/C/22/3312110) - 2 Stanley Park Litherland Liverpool L21 9JT - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for, without planning permission and within the last ten years, the change of use of the property from residential to a mixed use of residential and gym - commercial personal training facility.

 

Dismissed

 

11.09.23

Mr. B. Davenport

DC/2022/01085 (APP/M4320/W/22/3306975) - 2 Stanley Park Litherland Liverpool L21 9JT - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for the change of use of the property from residential to a mixed use of residential and gym - commercial personal training facility.

 

Dismissed

 

11.09.23

Mr. Edwards of EW Developments Ltd

DC/2022/01971 (APP/M4320/W/23/3319327) - 18-20 Hawthorne Road Bootle L20 2DN - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for the change of use of the ground floor only from retail (E) to self-contained flats (C3) including external alterations to the front, side and rear of the property.

 

Dismissed

 

26.09.23

Ms. M. Allen

DC/2023/00285 (APP/M4320/D/23/3324853) - 6 Thirlmere Road Hightown Liverpool L38 3RQ - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for the erection of a two-storey extension to the side with a rear first floor balcony and alterations to the rear of the dwellinghouse following demolition of existing detached garage.

 

Dismissed

 

21.09.23

Mr. P. Rooney

DC/2023/00147 (APP/M4320/D/23/3323991) - 1 Oulton Close Lydiate Liverpool L31 4JX - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for the erection of a single storey extension to the rear of the dwellinghouse.

 

Allowed

 

10.08.23

Mr. A. Bone

EN/2022/00416 (APP/M4320/C/22/3313776) - Abbey View Southport Road Lydiate Liverpool L31 4HH - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for the erection of a polytunnel / detached outbuilding within the curtilage of the property without planning permission[PF1] [IB2] .

 

Dismissed

Enforcement Notice Upheld

 

28.07.23

Mr. M. Zakurzewski

DC/2021/02960 (APP/M4320/W/22/3302854) - 38 Waller Street Bootle L20 4PU - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for the change of use from a dwellinghouse (C3) to a short-term holiday let (Sui Generis) (Retrospective).

 

Allowed

 

27.07.23

Mr. M. Zakurzewski

EN/2022/00159 (APP/M4320/C/22/3302856) - 38 Waller Street Bootle L20 4PU - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for, without planning permission and within the last 10 years, change of use from a dwellinghouse (C3) to a short term holiday let (Sui Generis).

 

Allowed, Enforcement Notice Quashed[PF3] 

 

27.07.23

Mr. K. Ben-Allal

EN/2022/00165 (APP/M4320/C/22/3303565) - 64 Thornfield Road Thornton Liverpool L23 9XZ - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant Planning Permission for[PF4] , without planning permission and within the last four years, alterations from a hipped to gable end roof to incorporate a rear dormer extension and erection of a single storey extension to the side and rear of the dwellinghouse.

 

Dismissed

Enforcement Notice Upheld

 

27.07.23

Mrs. S. McLoughlin

DC/2021/02928 (APP/TPO/M4320/9232) - 18 Tailors Lane Maghull L31 3HD - appeal against refusal by the Council to grant permission for the Tree Preservation Order application to fell 2 No. Horse Chestnut Trees (lies within TPO210).

 

Dismissed

 

26.07.23

 

Members noted that there was an 85% success rate on recent appeals and congratulated the team on their excellent performance.

 

RESOLVED:  

 

That the report be noted.

 


 [PF1]Hi Ian, do the words "without planning permission" need to be inserted here?

 [IB2]Sorted with planning

 [PF3]Hi Ian, is this the subject of an enforcement notice? If so, could the description be amended to reflect this?

 [PF4]Sorry Ian, are the words "without planning permission and within the last four years" required here?

Supporting documents: